Incorrect fit and a poor lacing method are a dangerous combination. They can cause a variety of foot ills, from blisters and hammertoes to foot disorders that are potentially disabling.
Forget what you may have been told about buying snug-fitting athletic shoes that will break in with time. If the shoes don't fit comfortably the first time you try them on, put them back and try on another pair.
If possible, try on athletic shoes right after you've done the activity for which you're buying the shoes. This is best because exercise makes your feet swell and will change the fit. Try running or walking to the shoe store. Another trick: Go to the shoe store at the end of the day, because that's when your feet will be their largest from all the walking and standing you've done.